Rapture Revisited Part 9: The Shame of “Easy Mode”

I’m going to share my secret shame. One of them, anyway.

A while back I posted on my Tumblr complaining that BioShock seemed much more difficult than the first time I played it. Ever since then—and please don’t think less of me for saying this, but…

I lowered the difficulty. I’ve been playing on “easy” mode.

Little Wonders

You know what? I don’t care. Not even a little. I don’t play games to exercise my fine motor skills and hand-eye coordination, nor am I driven to play by any kind of desire to compete.

(Good thing, that, because otherwise I’d be perpetually frustrated and miserable.)

I’ve been playing video games of one kind or another since the 1970’s. In all that time there were probably fewer than five games I mastered in terms of raw, mechanical gameplay. Pepper II on the ColecoVision was at the top of that list. It’s the only game where I ascended to the third level of mastery, that point where you no longer have to think or make moment-to-moment tactical decisions. When I was playing that game, everything around me would fall away. There was no living room, no television. There wasn’t even a controller in my hands. There was nothing but a continuum of light and sound and movement flowing unimpeded through my mind.

My high score was in the millions. After that game, as soon as I regained consciousness, I realized I would need proof of my accomplishment. I tried taking a direct picture of the TV screen with my old Kodak 110 camera. It didn’t work.

I’ve not experienced that kind of all-consuming, transcendent gameplay since then. I can’t say I miss it. I don’t think I’m the worse for having indulged in games that way, but neither do I have any desire to go back. Doing so would feel empty and pointless. It would be a waste of precious time.

Somewhere along the way, in between Mario Bros. and Portal, between Earthworm Jim and Ico, I stopped playing games to distract, amuse, or numb myself. I started playing games that made me think, games I could connect with on deeper levels: aesthetic, emotional, philosophical, social, and moral. Of course, they still had to be entertaining to warrant my interest, but entertainment was no longer the primary factor driving me to play.

A byproduct of this change is that I feel no compulsion to “beat” a game. I want it to be reasonably challenging, but I don’t feel I’m losing anything vital if I play on a medium or low difficulty setting. The correct difficulty for me is the one that best matches my abilities (pitiful though they may be). If the level of difficulty prevents me from enjoying everything else, down it goes.

At the same time, I was a little surprised at the difference betwen “medium” and “easy” in BioShock. There’s little or no challenge left in the game. Big Daddies went from being fearsome, hulking menaces to something more akin to nervous crossing guards in tinfoil suits. You don’t have to fight them so much as give them threatening looks.

It would’ve been nice to have another difficulty setting between “medium” and “easy”, but it’s no big deal. This playthrough was meant to be a quick study in preparation for Burial at Sea Episode 2, and it’s served that purpose well enough.

Good Girls

Now I’m off to find, fight, and finish Frank Fontaine! Given how easy the rest of the game has been, I don’t expect that’ll take much more than a sternly worded letter of disapproval.

Either that, or I’ll just show him a picture of that absurd “vocal chord modulator” you’re forced to use in this level & hope he faints.

4 thoughts on “Rapture Revisited Part 9: The Shame of “Easy Mode”

  1. I don’t think there’s any shame in playing through on easy mode. This is especially true if the game has an engrossing story and you want to experience the whole thing, but can’t get past a certain point. Though I don’t use it myself, I like how some games allow you to adjust the difficulty in the middle of the playthrough. That way, if you picked hard mode at the start and you feel like you’re in over your head, you can lower the difficulty instead of starting over from the beginning. Sure, a lot of purists mock their peers for even thinking about using easy mode, but when have they ever been right about anything?

    Anyway, I really like BioShock and BioShock: Infinite for their thought-provoking narratives and stellar gameplay. In fact, I like those games a lot more than I like their spiritual predecessor, System Shock 2, which, in hindsight, feels very clunky and unpolished.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Ken McGowan says:

      I agree completely. Games are, for me, almost entirely about the story. It’s rare these days I lose myself in a game that’s more about the mechanics. Because of that, the difficulty is really a means to an end. It should complement the story, not get in its way.

      But yeah, there are folks who tend to frown on that. :) Always have been, always will be. Oh well.

      My experience with System Shock 2 sounds similar to yours, too. I felt almost obligated to play given my appreciation for all things BioShock. I bailed very quickly, though. I still have it; not sure I’ll ever go back & finish it.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Ah, a connoisseur of story-heavy games, are you? If you haven’t played it, I highly recommend Planescape: Torment. To me, it’s the quintessential story-heavy game. It’s imaginative, captivating, and, most importantly, it complements the medium on which it was released. It’s easy enough to get too; it’s on GOG.com for a very low price. If you have a 3DS or DS, I also recommend Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors. Both of those games are admittedly very light on actual gameplay, but the writing more than makes up for that fact.

        I’d almost say that it’s worth playing System Shock 2 at least once, but has a major flaw which makes actually recommending it tricky. Specifically, its ending is absolutely abysmal. It’s difficult to explain why without context or spoilers, but considering how many people complain about the ending of BioShock: Infinite, it makes me wonder why those same people give the ending of System Shock 2 a pass; I firmly believe that it has the second-worst ending of any story-heavy game I’ve ever played.

        Liked by 1 person

        • Ken McGowan says:

          Thanks for the tip, I’ve added Planescape: Torment to my “To Play” list. I don’t actually have any kind of DS right now, but my son has been making noise time to time about wanting one. If he picks one up, I’ll have to borrow it. :)

          Liked by 1 person

So, what do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.